The Book of Lost Things by John ConnollyISBN: 9780743298858
Publication Date: 2006-11-07
One of my students was reading it—but there are multiple kinds of monsters in the land David gets sucked into in the story. This book is a coming-of-age adventure not unlike the Chronicles of Narnia, complete with Christian overtones, though they are much less pronounced. David is a young boy In World War II-era England, grieving his mother and unaccepting of his father’s new wife and son. He moves into his stepmother’s old house, hears books talking to him, sees a mysterious “crooked man” and before too long is in a faraway and magical land, trying to find his way home by going to the king to consult his Book of Lost Things. He of course learns an important lesson and is able to get home. There is a brief segment of the story where David expresses the homophobia typical of his day; this is not well resolved and I would not recommend the book to an unwary audience because of it, as it suggests and barely questions that gay men are typically pedophiles, a false and abhorrent statement. While I appreciated the inclusion of a gay character, and the knight Roland is a brave, wise, kind, and admirable human being, David’s reaction could be quite distressing to young (or not-so-young) LGBTQ readers or allies & family. There were some creative workings-in of many different fairy tale tropes, but overall it was somewhat predictable and tedious.
-Meredith, 2/5